From Steve Antonunccio
of NIAC (National Italian American Council)
and IAOV (Italian American One Voice)
Steve Antonunccio reports: Please find below today's
editorial in the
Rocky Mountain News.
I agree with the Rocky Mountain News. Let
them have their parade, as
long as they don't try and stop us with any illegal
activity or violence.
[RAA NOTE: In summary, The Editorial supports
Parades for Both the
Pro-Columbus, and Anti-Columbus groups. The Pro
Columbus group
has no intention of interference with Anti-Columbus
group, but factions
of the Anti-Columbus group acknowledges the possible
use of "direct
action" tactics.
Those actions take on a distinct probability...
"since (the Anti -Columbus
group) has also adopted the rhetorical trappings
of the anti-globalist
protests that have afflicted various international
gatherings. The "shared
principles" of the Transform Columbus Day alliance
even include the
rather incredible declaration that "The Columbus
legacy proceeds today
in, among other ways, neoliberalism and globalization."
"The last thing Denver needs is an anti-globalist
protest on the order of
Seattle or Genoa."... ]
=================================================
COLUMBUS, AGAIN: A POSITIVE
OPTION,
FINALLY TO THE PARADE
EDITORIAL: September 9, 2001
THE ISSUE: Anti-Columbus alliance unveils plans
OUR VIEW: Fine, so long as there aren't disruptions
Traditions can and do change. So there is nothing inevitable about
having an annual Columbus Day Parade -- or an alternative Four
Directions All Nations March, either, which activist Glenn Morris
describes as "an international mobilization to transform Columbus Day."
But if Morris and his allies can inspire enough people to join them
in
their inaugural event of Oct. 6, perhaps someday the march will displace
Columbus Day on the early October calendar, as the activists clearly
intend.
Or perhaps both events will appear on the calendar. The point is that
the anti-Columbus protesters seem finally to have come up with a
potentially positive alternative to their annual rite of trying to
shut
down a parade that organizers have every right to hold.
In a free society, the way to overcome what someone considers "hate
speech" is to persuade others to abandon it. And if the "hate speech"
involves a parade, then perhaps you need to offer an alternative march
that establishes itself as the dominant
attraction.
After all, Columbus was anything but an popular icon during the first
couple of centuries after his historic voyage in 1492 -- he was actually
returned to Spain in chains from his third voyage -- so it's far from
inevitable that his memory be marked forever with a
holiday and a parade. But those who wish to end either tradition must
do so through persuasion, not force.
The schedule of Transform Columbus Day activities actually extends
from Oct. 5 through 8, and includes several events in addition to the
Four Directions All Nations March. The big question is, will
those
events include another disruptive confrontation with the Columbus Day
Parade itself, with protesters attempting to suppress the free-speech
rights of Italian-Americans and theirsupporters? We hope not, but it's
a
distinct possibility. The coalition's Web site insists that "the alliance
acknowledges a diversity of tactics in combating the Columbus legacy,
ranging from education to direct action."
Direct action? Uh-oh.
And Morris himself told a News reporter that if there is such a parade,
"there will be massive opposition to it."
Even the less controversial events such as the Oct. 6 march are not
quite as "inclusive" as their supporters contend. The march will not
be
merely a celebration of all cultures; it has also adopted the rhetorical
trappings of the anti-globalist protests that have afflicted various
international gatherings. The "shared principles" of the Transform
Columbus Day alliance even include the rather incredible declaration
that "The Columbus legacy proceeds today in, among other ways,
neoliberalism and globalization."
The last thing Denver needs is an anti-globalist protest on the order
of
Seattle or Genoa. But as for a Four Directions All Nations March --
well, why not? It's a far more positive contribution to the community
than anything the anti-Columbus protesters have offered before.
|