Thanks to H-ITAM@H-NET.MSU.EDU
Salvator LaGumina, a founder and former president
of AIHA, has
generously donated to AIHA a supply of copies
of "WOP", the 1999
revised version of the 1973 original classic
collection of anti -Italian
literature in American history.
You can buy it from AIHA for $14 including postage.
Please send a check made out to: AIHA , and send
to
Dominic Candeloro
169 Country Club Rd.
Chicago Heights, IL 60411.
~" WOP! '~ A DOCUMENTARY
HISTORY OF ANTI-ITALIAN
DISCRIMINATION IN THE UNITED
STATES ........
SALVATORE J. LAGUMINA
PREFACE !
More than two decades ago my book, WOP: A Documentary History
of Anti-Italian Discrimination. became the first major publication
on the
topic of intolerance against Americans of Italian descent. That work
delineated the record of antagonism and hostility that awaited Italian
immigrants and their issue by recording discriminatory episodes that
were for the most part blunt, curt, and flagrant.
A revisit of the woeful terrain indicates that current anti-Italian
discrimination is manifestly disparate from the past in that whereas
in the pre-World War II era deprecating Italian Americans was blatant
and unapologetic, its contemporary counterpart is much more subtle
and elusive.
Discrimination in our times is in fact seemingly much less obvious,
much more implied and somewhat evasive , indeed circumstances
require that it appear to be more subdued in view of society's greater
sensitivity toward ethnic prejudice, in view also of the greater societal
prominence of Italian Americans in public life and of the anti-defamation
activity of Italian American organizations. But discrimination,
stereotyping and demeaning Italian Americans has not vanished;
it remains as a negative factor, albeit far less conspicuous.
The current basis for anti-Italian discrimination lies in stereotyping,
guilt by association and non-inclusion. Various television shows in
the
1970s and 1980s can be cited as promoting parodies and caricatures
of Italian Americans as silly, boisterous and ignorant thereby lending
credence to an unflattering image of people who best serve society
as
the butt of jokes, completely devoid of positive features that "deserve
comment let alone emulation.
While de facto exclusion of Italian Americans in certain fraternal and
recreation clubs is largely over, there are still instances in which
ethnicity remains an impediment. When avid golfer John A. Segalla,
a wealthy Connecticut builder, was denied membership in a golf club
because "you have an Italian name," he responded by building his own
golf club- in 1993.
As in the past linking Italian Americans with criminality remains the
predominant characteristic of stereotyping. Given a spate of popular
commercial and television movies such as Godfather I, Godfather II,
Godfather III, The Untouchables, and Goodfellas, it could almost be
guaranteed they would further reinforce Italian American criminality
in
the public mind.
Against this background it becomes possible, even acceptable, to
describe Tony Barone, a respected Creighton University basketball
coach, "with a face out of Goodfellas." One wonders whether the press
would have been so heedless in describing other ethnic groups with
disapproving connotations.
Acceptance of the criminal categorization stereotype is so endemic
that even otherwise esteemed jurists embrace its context. In his
lacerating decision while imposing life sentences to three convicted
mobsters in May 1993, Senior United States District Judge Jack B.
Weinstein relieved himself of observations which, while intended to
be
instructive, were widely condemned as destructive in that they
reinforced negative images. After hearing testimony that individuals
"had been lured into organized crime by the ethos of the neighborhood
as young twigs bent by their..seniors," Weinstein proceeded to assert,
"I believe there is a large part of the young Italo-American community
that should be discouraged from going into this line of work." It is
revealing to note that the pervasiveness of the stereotypical Italian
American malefactor persists even among respected members of
society.
Guilt by association is another insidious anti-Italian pattern. The
mere
suggestion that one bearing an Italian name is connected with
mobsters or illicit activity is enough to consign the unfortunate individual
to censure and disapproval. This was clearly illustrated in 1992 when
New York City Comptroller Elizabeth Holtzman recommending against
granting a city contract for a construction project to Frederick DeMatteis
of the Leon DeMatteis Construction Co., despite the fact that his
construction firm presented the lowest sealed bid for the work and
that
the firm had executed work projects satisfactorily for the city previously.
Holtzman's attempt to link DeMatteis with convicted mobsters by
insinuation, intimation and innuendo overrode ardent investigation
and
exculpation with the result that guilt by association placed DeMatteis
on the defensive. The latter, however, had the will and the resources
to
fight the smear tactic as well as the strong support of Italian American
organizations and went on to demonstrate that he had never been
connected with the named crime figures and was instead a bona fide
businessman who was victimized because of his Italian ancestry.
The truth of the matter was sustained by the New Jersey Casino
Control Commission which conducted a thorough review of his
application for a casino service industry license which it granted
in
January 1991. Vindication for DeMatteis, and by extension to
Italian
Americans, came in DeMatteis' appeal in a strongly worded brief of
October 7, 1992 in which New York :" Supreme Court Justice Alice
Schlesinger rebuked Holtzman and the city administration for
denying
DeMatteis a contract on spurious grounds that reflected ethnic prejudice.
Other than innuendo, speculation and guilt by association particularly
by one with an Italian surname, there is simply no evidence of a
probative value to show a link between petitioner and corrupt activity.
It was guilt by association or more accurately the alleged sins of the
father that formed the nexus of anti-Italian discrimination experienced
by New York City Corrections Commissioner Catherine Abate. Media
preoccupation with her father's supposed unsavory past, rather than
her exemplary record of twenty years of out-standing public service
followed her appointment to a major law enforcement position in the
nation's largest city. Italian American organizations denounced the
affair as inequitable and unjust maintaining individuals should be
judged
only by their own actions and not alleged actions of any parent.
The smear campaign notwithstanding, Abate was able to retain her
position. One can only speculate that this was due to the steadfast
support of Italian American organizations and officials.
While federal, state and city law-enforcement officials maintain that
ordinarily agencies do not investigate backgrounds of people seeking
positions there are exceptions leading to speculate that these
exceptions escalate when Italian Americans are involved.
Altogether sufficient data has surfaced to indicate that discrimination
still abides. While the grossest, bluntest and most desensitized
examples of yesteryear happily have been relegated to the dust bin
of
history, the more sophisticated, astute and elusive types remain on
the
scene to varying degrees. Anti-discrimination laws, greater sensitivity
and proper education have all helped to diminish discrimination of
course; however, it would be foolish in the extreme to believe that
bigotry is over. Without succumbing to paranoia it seems prudent to
be
aware of its pernicious presence and detrimental possibilities.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Preface
1 Introduction.
9 Anti-Italianism: The Embryonic Stage , (Pre-1880)
21 The Maturation of Anti-Italianism (1880-1890)
52 Xenophobia During the High Tide:- of Italian Immigration (1890-1914)
72 Roman Catholicism as an Obstacle-, to Assimilation (1890-1914)
163 The Establishment's Solution to the "Foreign Problem" (1914-1930)
181 'Anti-Italianism in the Vortex of Economic and Political Turmoil
(1930-1945)
227 The Post-World War II Period: Ongoing Problems
247 Notes
313 Bibliography
GUERNICA .. TORONTO.BUFFALO.LANCASTER (U.K.) ~ 1999 - ~
Copyright @ 1973, by Salvatore J. LaGumina and Straight Arrow Books.
Copyright @ 1999, by Salvatore J. LaGumina and Guernica Editions Inc.
WOP! was originally published in 1973 by Straight Arrow Books, New
York.
Excerpted articles appear in their original form without alteration
or
correction by the publisher.
Antonio D' Alfonso, Editor. Guernica Editions Inc. RO. Box 117, Station
~
Toronto (ON), Canada M5S 2S6 2250 Military Rd., Tonawanda, N.Y 14150-6000
U.S.A. Gazelle, Falcon House, Queen Square, Lancaster lA11RN U.K.
|