Thanks to Dominic Candeloro
at H-ITAM/AIHA
Dominic refers us to an article appearing in the
Washinton Post, Sunday,
December 23, 2001, by George Will titled
"Our National Memory Loss"
Will referred to Lynne Cheney (Mrs. VP-and an
education advocate)
comments on the woeful state of ignorance of
students re American History,
at even in the most prestigious colleges. (See
excerpt or URL below).
Dominic commented: <<If our young people
don't know the basic national
history of the US, how can we expect them to
know anything about ethnic
or Italian American history????>>
To just lay the foundation, for a response, IMHO,
I agree with Cheney and
Will when they infer that, It is abysmal what
passes for a college education
today. Between "fluff" courses, "politically
correct courses", and "wholesale"
cheating it is not unexpected to see the graduates
coming out relatively
unscathed by the experience.
But to respond to the gist of Dominic's remark.
First, it sounds too much like an EXCUSE not to
advocate for Italian
American Studies.
Second, At least American History is OFFERED,
though it might not be
REQUIRED. It's REALLY Tuff trying to take a Course
that is NOT offered*,
like Italian American History!!! (* with rare
exception)
Third, Those same students that don't know "diddley"
about American History
are undoubtedly those same ones that are too
busy taking courses regarding
THEIR ETHNIC, RACIAL, HOLOCAUST, GENDER, INDIGENOUS
PEOPLES, ALTERNATIVE LIFE STYLES etc.,
/ STUDIES, and don't have
time/inclination for what they erroneously view
as "Old White American Guys"
History. They ARE too busy Studying THEIR "More
Personal" Histories!
So, let me get this straight. We are NOT as many
say, becoming more
Americanized, but more "Fragmentized/Tribalized",
while the Italian American
Community stands around with their finger in
their ear, caught in a "time warp",
where they are still buying into the concept
of the "Homogenized/Assimilated"
American, while there has been a 180 degree shift
to the "Mosaic/ Stew"
American Perspective.
What are we giving our kids to "Identify" with?
How do we make it possible
to learn about THEIR I-A Culture. The Italian
American Community is NOT
adequately pressuring the Colleges and Universities
to provide Italian
American History Courses.
Yes, Frank Cannata reminds us that we have Chairs
at UCONN, John Davis
(Noether Chair in Modern Italian History), and
at Seton Hall, William Connell
(LaMotta Chair), and the D'Amato Chair at SUNY
Stony Brook, with Professor
Fred Gardaphe as Director of the Italian-American
Institute. [Carlo
Chiarenza (Graziedio Chair), at University of
California Long Beach is
considering incorporating I-A Studies].
I commend those responsible for those achievements,
but they deserve
more Vigorous support, from a more Involved and
Determined I-A Community.
Until more members of NIAF, OSIA, UNICO Insist
that "Italian American
Studies" be given priority on their Agendas,
progress will be at a snails pace.
Each Chapter, should be pressuring their National
HQ !!!!!
Also, consider that OSIA, NIAF, UNICO Scholarship
programs currently in
place be modified to support ONLY those I-A students
pursuing Italian
American Studies!!!!!! Scholarships for mere
General Studies are not the most
efficacious expenditure of the Communities limited
Resources. This topic
deserves a revisit.
Lastly, "Cheney says..."Advancement in academia
comes from publishing,
and there is little market in academic journals
for articles on subjects that
are broadly conceived." Academic laurels go to
authors of specialized articles,
who prefer to teach specialized courses, so general
education is slighted."
I have the similar impression that even where
Italian Studies are written about,
that the subject matter I-A Academicians are
generally much too esoteric, or
"niche".
How can we expect our kids to know who they are,
and from whence they
came, if we don't provide the tools (the Courses),
for them to find out!!!!!
=========================================================
Excerpt from Washington Post Article:
A 1999 survey of college seniors at 55 elite colleges, from Princeton
to
Stanford, revealed that only 22 percent knew that the words "government
of
the people, by the people, for the people" are from the Gettysburg
Address.
Forty percent could not place the Civil War in the second half of the
19th
century. Only 44 percent could place Lincoln's presidency in the period
1860-1880.
Fifty-nine percent thought Reconstruction was about repairing the physical
damage done by the Civil War. Twenty-five percent thought the pilgrims
signed
the Magna Carta on the Mayflower. Sixty-three percent did not know
the Battle
of the Bulge was in World War II. To the question of who commanded
American
forces at Yorktown, the most frequent answer was Ulysses S. Grant.
Such questions should not be difficult for high school seniors. But
at the time
of the survey, none of the 55 colleges and universities required a
course in
American history. And students could graduate from 78 percent of them
without
taking any history course.
|