Tuesday,
January 08,
"Italian-Americans Rip Rudy as an
UNCLE TOMASO," blared the
The
ANNOTICO Report
Richard
Cappozzola, author of Five Centuries of Italian
Americans, single handed got the attention of two important East Coast Dailies.
Richard
lives near
I
like the Power of Many !!! But here, The
Power of One, Impressive
Bad Press? Giuliani Gets It Good
By Howard Kurtz
Staff Writer
Monday, January 7, 2008; C01
"Italian-Americans
Rip Rudy as an UNCLE TOMASO," blared the Boston Herald's cover, citing a single activist who
doesn't like the way Giuliani jokes about mobsters.
The former New
York mayor assumes that bad press comes with the presidential campaign
territory. "I never see myself as a victim," he says in an interview.
"I don't like seeing myself that way. . . . There've been negative stories
about everyone. Maybe it's more a function of being a front-runner."
At a policy
level, though, Giuliani is convinced that he and his GOP
brethren don't get a fair shake. "I think there is a liberal bias in the
media toward Democratic approaches and Democratic candidates," he says.
"Republicans have to go against the grain when we're talking about
Republican or conservative solutions. . . . I've encountered that from the very
beginning."
Giuliani has his
share of self-inflicted wounds, and the less than sympathetic coverage is
amplified by a campaign style in which the onetime prosecutor gives little
ground and doesn't hesitate to throw punches. He generates few
warm-and-fuzzy stories because of his no-nonsense demeanor on the trail, a
largely humorless approach in which he talks terrorism and taxes but not about
himself.
Giuliani shakes
few hands after speaking, often departing within one minute. Last Wednesday,
after a speech at a World War II museum in Wolfeboro about his call to expand
the military, he slipped away to do interviews with conservative radio hosts Bill
O'Reilly and Dennis Prager and with Fox
News.
Addressing 40
people at a Somersworth restaurant featuring a $7.49 lunch buffet that includes
whoopie pie, Giuliani answered questions from two
disabled people -- who asked how he would help people like them -- with
bloodless policy talk. Giuliani did not inquire about their conditions or
express any sympathy. He did, however, take a stand on a pamphlet
containing his 12 commitments, saying: "It's like a contract. If I don't
do it, you can sue me."
While other
candidates appear softened by the presence of family members, the Boston
Globe ran a piece last week noting that Giuliani's third wife, Judith,
has largely been absent from campaigning.
And then there is
his temerity in arguing that he can win the nomination without strong showings
in Iowa
(where he finished sixth, with 3 percent of the vote) and tomorrow in New
Hampshire -- a strategy that runs smack into the media's conventional
wisdom. "Most national political reporters write off or disparage his
chances of winning," Time's Mark
Halperin reported last week.
As if to
underscore his unorthodox approach, Giuliani campaigned here the day before the
In a news
conference at the restaurant, one reporter cited a poll that gives John
McCain the lead among Republican voters nationwide, saying: "You've
always led in the national polls. How do you explain that?" Giuliani said
he was not good at explaining polls.
Another reporter,
noting that nearly all his rivals were in
"We're doing
okay," Giuliani said.
From the moment
he entered the race, many pundits insisted that
conservatives would abandon Giuliani once they learned more about his
liberal views on abortion and other social issues. When he continued to
lead the field, reporters and commentators began questioning how he could
survive expected losses before getting to his preferred battlegrounds of
The media
narrative for Giuliani is that he's built his candidacy around one event, his
response to the attack on the World
Trade Center. He did little to dispel that notion in
Whatever the
subject, Giuliani is a constant target of investigative reporters. There was
even media skepticism about the recent illness -- described as a severe
headache -- that sidelined him for a couple of days. But after two decades'
sparring with the tabloid-tough
On the day
Giuliani declared his first mayoral bid in 1989, the New
York Daily News reported that the Manhattan
law firm he had recently joined represented the Panamanian government of
strongman Manuel
Noriega, all but overshadowing the announcement. Similar questions have
dogged his presidential campaign, such as a recent New
York Times story on his firm Giuliani
Partners' representing Purdue Pharma, which last
spring admitted misleading doctors and patients about the painkiller OxyContin and paid penalties of $635 million. Giuliani
has declined to reveal his firm's client list on grounds of confidentiality.
Another constant
source of coverage involves his personal life. In 1997, when NY1 cable reporter
Dominic Carter asked Giuliani about rumors that he had had an affair with a
staffer, the mayor accused him of having "no decency." Giuliani's
messy divorce from Donna Hanover in 2000 turned his life into a soap opera for
the press.
Last spring,
after a spate of snarky pieces about his wife,
Judith, Giuliani urged reporters to back off, saying: "Attack me all you
want. . . . But maybe, you know, show a little decency."
In November, when
the Politico reported that Giuliani had billed obscure city agencies
thousands of dollars in security costs for Judith Nathan while she was his
girlfriend, he branded the report false and accused the paper of a
"political hit job."
During an
hour-long interrogation by Tim
Russert on "Meet the Press" last month,
Giuliani became the first presidential candidate ever to be asked: "Would
it be appropriate for a president to provide Secret
Service protection for his mistress?"
In late December,
the Times carried a small article reporting that Giuliani did bill his own
mayoral expense account for security on trips to the
Profile pieces
rarely fail to mention the controversies stemming from his mayoral tenure, such
as the criminal charges against his friend and former police commissioner, Bernard
Kerik. And journalists never have
trouble finding former city officials to badmouth their onetime boss.
In a New Yorker
piece last week, Jerome Hauer, former head of the
city's Office of Emergency Management, now a Hillary
Clinton supporter, was quoted as saying: "From my perspective, Rudy
would be a very dangerous president." Rudy Crew, a former schools
chancellor, said of his falling out with Giuliani: "It's
tragic how wounded this man really is. And wounded people inevitably wound
other people."
If Giuliani is
steamed about such stories, he isn't letting on. "Being from
Asked for
examples of what he deems biased coverage, Giuliani says that whenever he
argued for vouchers to allow students to attend the school of their choice,
"we were attacked -- I hate to overgeneralize --
by the liberal media, or some big portion of it, for
wanting to destroy public schools. . . .
"If I say
something like 'you can't take any military option off the table with regard to
Iran,'
all of a sudden . . . that's seen as wanting to go to war."
On the night that
Mike
Huckabee won the
Since then,
Giuliani has suffered a worse fate: garnering little coverage from journalists
chasing other candidates. (One exception was yesterday's Washington
Post piece: "As N.H. Voters See Less of Giuliani, He Drops in State
Polls.") The question is when, and whether, he can grab the spotlight back
The
ANNOTICO Reports Can be Viewed (and are Archived) on:
Italia
Italia Mia: http://www.ItaliaMia.com (3 years)
Annotico
Email: annotico@earthlink.net