Tuesday,
December 16, 2008
Bernard Madoff Has Italian Victims in $50
The
ANNOTICO Report
Bernard
Madoff, a highly respected Stock Broker/Tader, and former chairman of the
NASDAQ Stock Market,
was arrested and charged with securities fraud, which may rank among the
biggest frauds ever - totaling $50
A
Ponzi scheme is a fraudulent investment operation that involves
paying abnormally high returns to investors out of the money paid in by
subsequent investors, rather than from the profit from any real business. It is
named after Charles Ponzi.
While
many proceeded Ponzi in 1920, such as Sarah Howe, who in 1880 opened up a
"Ladies Deposit" in
Madoff
collected Investments through "agents" such as Fairfield
Greenwich Group, Tremont Group Holdings Inc, , Alpha Capital
Management LLC, London-based FIM Ltd., Kingate Europe and Kingate Global Funds,
and others, who also had sub agents.
Walter
Noels Fairfield Greenwich Group, one of the bigger losers at 7
Kingate
Bloomberg News
By Katherine Burton
December 15, 2008
Walter
Noels Fairfield Greenwich Group would have collected about $135
million in fees this year for peddling Bernard Madoffs
investing acumen to clients from South America, the Middle East and
The $7.3 billion Fairfield
Sentry Fund invested solely with Madoff, taking a cut of 1 percent of
assets and 20 percent of gains, which averaged about 11 percent annually in the
past 15 years, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Tremont Group Holdings Inc.
had $3.3 billion in Madoff accounts, according to a person familiar with the
matter. They were among at least 15 hedge-fund firms and private banks that earned
fees for sending customers cash to the 70-year-old money manager.
Its
mind-boggling that people like Tremont and Fairfield Greenwich had been doing
this for so long, said Brad
Alford, who runs Alpha Capital Management LLC
in Atlanta, which helps clients choose hedge funds. Its the job of
these funds of funds to be doing due diligence. Thats why they get
paid.
Madoff was
arrested Dec. 11 after he allegedly confessed to running a giant Ponzi
scheme that may have bilked investors of $50 billion. That fraud escaped
the notice of Fairfield Greenwich, Tremont and other funds of funds that had at
least $20.3 billion invested with Madoff. Hedge-fund investment adviser Aksia
LLC said the managers should have seen red flags, such as Madoffs
use of a little-known, three-person auditing firm.
Fund Fees
Hedge funds that
have disclosed holdings with Madoff were due at least $352 million in fees this
year, based on reported assets, fees and Bloomberg data. The calculations
dont include fees of as much as 5 percent that clients paid for some funds
when they first invested. Madoff didnt assess fees for his
money-management services, getting paid instead through commissions from his
brokerage business for trading the stocks in the accounts.
Investors ensnared
by Madoff include Fred
Wilpon, the owner of the New York Mets baseball team, clients of private
bankers in
Investor
Defections
While Madoff
didnt run a hedge fund, his alleged crime may accelerate investor
defections from the $1.5 trillion industry, already hit by its worst losses
since at least 1990 and redemptions that may reach $400 billion this year,
according to estimates by Morgan Stanley. In a Ponzi scheme, returns to early
investors are paid with money from later ones, until there isnt enough
cash to go around. Madoffs alleged scam unraveled when he received $7
billion in redemption requests that he couldnt meet.
Funds of hedge
funds such as Fairfield Greenwich act as middlemen, raising money from
investors and farming it out to other managers that they vet. The go-betweens
manage 44 percent of hedge-fund assets, according to data compiled by Hedge Fund Research Inc. Their
investments lost 19 percent on average through November, a little more than a
percentage point more than single-manager funds, the Chicago-based firm says.
Institutions
including
Due Diligence
Funds of funds
say they earn their fees by discovering the best managers and assembling a
diversified group of investments. They also are supposed to conduct ongoing due
diligence to avoid frauds or other dangers, such as managers straying from
their core investment strategy.
Fairfield
Greenwich is the biggest loser to emerge so far from the Madoff scandal. It had
more than half its $14.1 billion in assets with him, according to a company
statement.
We are
shocked and appalled by the news, said founding partner Jeffrey
Tucker in a Dec. 12 statement. Tucker was an attorney in the enforcement
division of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission before starting
Fairfield Greenwich with Noel in 1983. Thomas Mulligan, a spokesman for
Fairfield Greenwich, declined to comment.
Family Business
Noel built a
marketing machine that covered the globe. His son-in-law, Yanko Della Schiava,
is based in
Three months ago,
the firm acquired Banque Benedict Hentsch, a deal that the Swiss private bank
said today it has reversed.
Tremont, founded
by Sandra
Manzke in 1985, also was an early Madoff investor. The Rye, New York-based
firm, a unit of Massachusetts Mutual Life Insurance Co.s OppenheimerFunds Inc.,
sold Madoff-managed investments since 1997 under the Rye Select Broad Market
name, charging 2 percent of assets, according to a marketing document.
Tremonts Rye
Investment Management unit had $3.1 billion, or virtually all its assets,
invested with Madoff, said the person, who declined to be identified because
the information is private. Tremont had another $200 million invested through
its fund of funds group.
A spokesman for
Tremont declined to comment.
Wealthy Clients
Manzke now runs
Darien, Connecticut-based MAXAM
Capital Management LLC, which marketed a $280 million fund that was
invested solely with Madoff. Manzke told the Wall Street Journal she was wiped
out. Manzke didnt return calls or e-mails.
Another Madoff
investor is London-based FIM Ltd., whose Kingate Europe and Kingate Global
funds had about $3.5 billion in assets as of the end of November, according to
reports sent to clients. The firm, run by Carlo
Grosso, marketed the funds to many wealthy Italian families. Kingate
collected a 5 percent fee to get into the funds and a management fee of 1.5
percent of assets.
Access
International Advisors LLC, a New York-based investment firm, charged a 5
percent fee up front, a 0.8 percent management fee and a 16 percent performance
fee on its LUXALPHA
SICAV-American Selection fund, according to Bloomberg data.
Bank Fees
Swiss private
banks also sent money to Madoff. Union Bancaire Privee, the largest investor in
hedge funds, had a managed account called M-Invest that was a direct conduit
into Madoff, people familiar with the situation said. Benbassat & Cie,
another Swiss bank, had $935 million invested in Madoff on behalf of clients,
according to Le Temps.
Scott
Berman, a lawyer at Friedman
Kaplan Seiler & Adelman LLP in New York, who specializes in hedge-fund
litigation, said hes gotten numerous calls from investors who had money
with feeder funds such as Fairfield Greenwich and Tremont, and plans to
investigate whether these funds failed to do due diligence or if they invested
in ways that were contrary to what they told investors.
Calling Lawyers
Ross
Intelisano, a lawyer at New York-based Rich & Intelisano LLP,
which also specializes in hedge-fund litigation, said there may be attempts by
investors to get money back from fellow clients who withdrew money from Madoff
accounts before the fraud was uncovered.
You will have
members of country clubs and members of families on opposite sides of this
case. It will rip up communities and families, he said.
When Aksia
researched Madoff last year, it learned the firms books were audited by
accountants Friehling & Horowitz, operating out of a 13-by-18 foot location
in an office park in
Other details
that made Aksia nervous included the high degree of secrecy
surrounding the trading of the feeder fund accounts, which provided capital to
Madoff Securities, and its use of a trading strategy that appeared
remarkably simple, yet could not be nearly replicated by our
quant analyst, Aksia wrote in a Dec. 11 letter to its clients.
To contact the
reporter on this story: Katherine Burton in
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601103&sid=a0TEG4yetMg4&refer=us
The
ANNOTICO Reports Can be Viewed (With Archives) on
Italia