
Wednesday, March 10, 2010
The Triangle Fire - Wealthy Jews
vs Poor Jews and Italians
The Calandra Institute has announced
a dedication Ceremony on March 25, 2010, the 99th Anniversary of
the Most Tragic Disaster in NYC History, that is until the Twin Towers
on 9-11.
The list of 146 dead (there were 70
injured) about evenly divided between Italian and Jewish can be found at:
http://knickerbockervillage.blogspot.com/2009/03/
triangle-shirtwaist-factory-fire-david.html
The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire
in New York City on March 25, 1911, was one of the largest industrial disasters
in the history of the city of New York, causing the death of 146 garment
workers, almost all of them women, who either died from the fire or jumped
from the fatal height. It was the worst workplace disaster in New York
City until September 11, 2001. Most women could not escape the burning
building because the managers would lock the doors to the stairwells and
exits to keep the workers from taking cigarette breaks outdoors during
their shifts. Women jumped from the ninth and tenth stories as the ladders
on the fire trucks could not reach these. The fire led to legislation requiring
improved factory safety standards and helped spur the growth of the International
Ladies' Garment Workers' Union, which fought for better and safer working
conditions for sweatshop workers in that industry. The Triangle Shirtwaist
Factory was located inside the Asch Building, now known as the Brown Building
of Science. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triangle_Shirtwaist_Factory_fire
Triangle Shirtwaist Factory, on the
eighth, ninth and 10th floors of the Joseph J. Asch building, in New York
City. Their employers, Isaac Harris and Max Blanck " known throughout the
burgeoning shmatte business as "the shirtwaist kings",They had several
locations, but the Trianglewas the largest blouse-making factory
in the city,had managed to beat back unionization attempts by the fledgling
International Ladies Garment Workers Union, were successful in getting
some mearure of reform. This was the era when Jews were both owners
and workers. But, the Triangle owners resisted unionization. As a
result, 140 of the factory’s workers, most of them young women, would die
that Sabbath in one of the most tragic fires in American history.
In his riveting new book, "Triangle:
The Fire that Changed America," Washington Post reporter David Von
Drehle couches the story of the fire in the social and political history
of the time. Von Drehle weaves the Triangle episode ...of the Eastern European
Jewish experience in America's slavery like "seat shops" to collide
with Blanck and Harris who were part of the privileged upper class.
"Max Blanck was a well-fed, moon-faced man with a big Daddy Warbucks head
and beefy hands," writes Von Drehle. "He rode around in a chauffeur-driven
car. Isaac Harris was smaller, sharper, with rodentlike features and piercing
eyes. They lived in splendor near the Hudson River in neighboring town
houses" http://www.forward.com/articles/8220/
Because the Asch Building was only
to be 135 feet tall, it was allowed to have wood floors, wood window frames
and trim, instead of the metal trim, metal
window frames, and stone or concrete
floors that would have been required in a 150 feet tall building. Sprinklers
were not required but there was to be a fire alarm system as well as a
standpipe with hoses on all the floors connecting to a water tank on the
roof. The plans called for two staircases, The plans also included
an external iron fire escape on the north wall.On May 7, the Buildings
Department issued an objection sheet, indicating that an additional line
of fire stairs was required for the building’s area of 10,000 square feet
per floor. The examiner also objected to the rear fire escape, indicating
that it “must lead to something more substantial than a skylight.” Woolley
responded over the next two days, agreeing to correct the objections and
requesting an exemption for the other stair. The exemption was granted
Many workers considered Blanck and
Harris among the worst employers in the industry. The partners were heedless
of the numerous fire and safety fire hazards at their factory. They routinely
ignored labor laws aimed at protecting women and children. Employees were
expected to work until as late as nine o’clock at night during the busy
season, without overtime pay or a supper break, and they were locked in
to ensure they would not leave the building. Employees were required to
submit their bags for inspection before leaving work and the doors were
locked to make sure that everyone complied. Talking and singing were forbidden
during working hours;bathroom breaks were monitored; there were fines for
errors; and workers had to buy their own needles,thread, and other supplies.
At the time of the Fire, A manager
ran to the stairwell for a fire hose, only to realize that the hose had
rotted and the water valve had rusted shut. Soon, the room was engulfed
with flame and smoke. Most of the occupants of the eighth floor escaped.
A few young panic-stricken women, who had not been able to fit into the
elevator or reach the crowded fire stairs and fire escape, jumped out of
the windows to their deaths. The executive offices on the tenth floor were
alerted to the fire. Someone called the fire department, but no one contacted
the 260 workers on the ninth floor.
Few workers knew there was a fire
escape in the courtyard since the iron shutters on the courtyard windows
were routinely closed. The few workers that found their way onto the rickety
seventeen-inch-wide iron fire escape, but, the drop ladder that would have
brought them safely to the courtyard below had never been installed. A
number of the escape doors had been chained shut to better "control" worker
movement, i.e bathroom breaks. The fire department’s life nets were utterly
useless to withstand the force of bodies falling from the ninth floor and
their ladders were too short to reach the fire floors.
http://www.neighborhoodpreservationcenter.org/
db/bb_files/2003BrownBuilding.pdf
Triangle was a sweatshop: hundreds
of workers -- many of them young immigrant girls -- working long hours
for low wages in abysmal conditions. The girls, some of them as young as
twelve or thirteen, worked fourteen-hour shifts during a 72-hour workweek,
and made about $1.50 per week. {2 cents an hour)
Both the insurance industry and owners
preferred a system whereby high premiums were paid instead of requiring
safety provisions and paying lower premiums. The Triangle owners did collect
a large sum of money from the fire. Twenty three individual suites against
the owners of the Asch building, were settled at a rate of seventy five
dollars per life lost.
Book: "The Triangle Fire" by
Leon Stein @
http://www.amazon.com/Triangle-Fire-Leon-Stein/
product-reviews/0801487145
Book: "Triangle: The Fire that Changed
America". by David von Driehle
Film: "The Triangle Factory Fire
Scandal" Directed by Emmy-winner Mel Stuart, http://fly.hiwaay.net/~djberry/movies/firescan.htm
The ANNOTICO Reports Can be
Viewed (With Archives) on:
[Formerly
Italy at St Louis]
|