Both James Scalzitti's, and Bill Del Cerro Monthly
Column in Fra Noi
are a must read for any Italian American who has pride in their Culture.
==============================
MEDIAWATCH by James Scalzitti
(1) WHAT'S THE BIG DEAL?
(2) LEAVING A BAD TASTE
(3) TOW ZONE?
(4) RADIO WATCH
----------------------------------------------------------
(1) WHAT'S THE BIG DEAL?
One of my favorite radio shows is Roe Conn and Garry Meier’s talker
on WLS-AM
in Chicago. The two guys are funny, witty and smart; not especially
political
and not shock jocks. They have, at times, used Italian-American character
voices on the air, but they poke fun in some way at every sort of ethnic
and
racial group, and they often make fun of themselves, as well. Besides,
unlike
other radio personalities, I’ve never felt that their Italian-flavored
bits
were ever malevolent.
Because there have recently been some news stories regarding the defamation
of some other groups (see below) Roe and Garry were talking about the
subject
one afternoon recently. I caught the tail end of a caller who evidently
had
mentioned the negative media portrayals of Italian Americans, and our
reaction to them, but I heard all of what the show’s hosts had to say.
In essence, their opinion was that Italians have somehow managed to
do quite
well in American society in spite of the fact that so many believe
us to be
“connected” or dull-witted or dishonest in some way, and thus we shouldn’t
complain about any parodies that pop up in the media, whether they
are “The
Sopranos” or a radio commercial that uses a caricature of an Italian-American
to sell sandwiches.
The good news that was almost lost in their on-air wondering of why
we
complain so much, was that they acknowledged our anti-defamation efforts.
The
duo said that our anti-defamation groups, at least in Chicago, are
very
active and very vocal. “They have an anti-defamation group that is
very, very
hostile toward the media,” was one comment the hosts made. Really?
Are we
hostile toward CBS for putting shows like “That’s Life,” “Everybody
Loves
Raymond” and “First Monday” on the air? Are we hostile toward companies
like
the Olive Garden for the commercials they air? Are we hostile toward
companies that produce and distribute films like “Big Night” and “Life
is
Beautiful?” I think not.
While I did not jot down which of the show’s hosts was making what comments,
the two of them concurred on every comment that the other made, especially
“I
find it kinda funny that one of the most prosperous groups in America
(makes
such a big deal out of the incessant attacks on our character). The
Italian
experience in America is one of great success, as are the Jews. Groups
that
are very prosperous who want to defend themselves … I FIND THAT A WASTE
OF
TIME.”
Prosperous? Oh great, so if we’re not being stereotyped as lazy, criminal
and
stupid, we’re thought to be among the richest people in the country!
How did
they conduct this poll? If we’re so prosperous, why isn’t Fra Noi printed
on
glossy paper? If we’re so prosperous, why do so many Italian-American
couples
I know work two and three jobs between them to provide for their children
and
try to secure a future for their family? If we’re so prosperous, why
aren’t
we all driving Cadillac Escalades? Yeah, I know some Italian Americans
who
are doing pretty well — and the reason why they’re making decent money
is
BECAUSE THEY HAVE BUSTED THEIR ASSES IN MEDICAL SCHOOL AND LAW SCHOOL
AND
NIGHT SCHOOL AND WALKING THROUGH THE SEWERS OF CITIES ALL OVER THIS
COUNTRY
AND CRAWLING UNDER SINKS FOR A LIVING AND RUNNING INTO BURNING BUILDINGS
AND
BUSTING DRUG DEALERS so everyone, Italian or not, could live in comfort
and
safety.
OK, besides the fact that that’s a ridiculous stereotype, that we’re
all
“prosperous,” let’s play devil’s advocate here. Let’s say that we were
covered with a blanket of prosperity. So that means we shouldn’t raise
our
voices when someone attacks us? We wouldn’t hold on to our prosperity
for
long, then, would we? And, do they mean to imply that because the Jews
are
also “prosperous” (sounds like an argument that’s been used quite a
bit by
those who’d wish the Jews ill), that they shouldn’t complain either?
At the
risk of using a term that I swore I would not utter this year, I’m
not even
going to go there.
“It really is, in the long run, harmless,” is what Roe and Garry said
about
the caricatures and parodies and defamatory characterizations of Italian
Americans that we have to wade through each day. I would argue otherwise,
especially since it seems that every time we turn around, we are bombarded
by
another one of these attacks.
I’m not going to stop listening to Roe and Garry’s show because I disagree
with the opinions that were expressed one afternoon in April. They’re
funny
and informative and because I’m not one of those “prosperous” Italians,
I
need to work for “the man” and their show does keep me awake in the
afternoons. Nor will I call for a massive letter-writing or e-mail
campaign
into their station. They expressed their opinions, and I am certain
they were
not being malicious, just ill-informed. The solution is not to yell
or to
march in protest, but to educate. We need to explain to them in a friendly
tone how these things affect us and how they just wear us down over
time and
how we’d really like it to stop.
---------------------------------------------------------
(2) LEAVING A BAD TASTE
Sometimes I just feel like throwing my hands up in the air, like I just
don’t
care, and saying, “That’s it, I’ve had it, it’s no use.” True, there
are a
handful of dedicated, vigilant activists across the country who are
making
inroads in our never-ending battle against defamation. Then I hear
about
things such as the following. Quizno’s, the quasi-Italian-esque subway
sandwich chain has a new radio commercial that features a spelling
contest
between a college professor and a crude, vulgar Italian-American character
named Carducci, who couldn’t even spell his own name. (And this is
meant to
sell sandwiches how?) Carducci then becomes frustrated and starts shouting
out a string of obscenities (bleeped out). From what I’ve heard, Quiznos
has
so far refused to return calls from Italian-American activists or address
the
commercial at all. If you would like to express your opinion to the
people at
Quizno’s, drop them an e-mail, at www.quiznos.com/contactus.asp.
--------------------------------------------------------------
(3) TOW ZONE?
A reader from Florida, Dr. Salvatore Nuzzarello, sent us a photo of
a sign in
a church parking lot near his home. The sign read “MAFIA CHAPLAIN PARKING
ONLY — FINE 2 BROKEN LEGS.” The “2” was in a fish, one of the symbols
of
Christianity, which conveys the message of peace. Dr. Nuzzarello contacted
the pastor of the church, and found out that the pastor, an Italian
American
himself, was the one who had the sign put up, and apparently, this
man of God
thinks this sign is funny. Funny how? According to Dr. Nuzzarello,
the word
“Mafia” in the sign is supposed to stand for an organization called
the
Mother’s and Father’s Italian Association, but he adds that there is
no such
organization, it’s just a stupid reason to use the word “Mafia” in
a
supposedly “funny” way.
The sign, while insignificant to those who don’t see this stuff all
around
and while apparently funny to those who are amused by it, offends me
on so
many levels. It offends me as a Catholic because it implies that the
power of
God is secondary to the “power” of some criminal organization, even
if, in
this case, “MAFIA” stands for some non-existent organization. There
is an
implied message that is none too subtle, especially when you throw
in the
“fine” of “(two) broken legs.” It offends me as an Italian American
because
it only reinforces the widely held belief that all of us are in some
way
“connected,” and we can’t get anything or achieve anything without
the
assistance of the mob. It offends me as someone with good taste, because,
well, it just looks stupid and makes the person behind it (much like
those
people who once thought they’d look cool by slapping a “Mafia Staff
Car”
bumper sticker on their autos) look stupid.
Dr. Nuzzarello sent a letter to Bishop John Nevins of Venice, Fla. voicing
his dismay, and asking for a response, but there’s no word yet of hearing
back from the bishop on this matter.
-----------------------------------------------------
(4) RADIO WATCH
The next item doesn’t involve Italian Americans directly, but it does
bear
watching by all of us. I have in the past written about Mike North,
a radio
host at WSCR-AM in Chicago, a sports talk station. Basically he likes
to
perpetuate the whole wiseguy myth, as in a simulcast this past winter
with a
radio station in Philadelphia, in which he made comments such as “I
don’t
wanna mess with you,” when he heard the Italian surname of one of the
Philadelphia radio hosts.
Well, this time North has dared to pick on someone other than Italian
Americans. In late March, North commented on a new television news
anchor in
town, former network newsman Antonio Mora. North said, on the air,
that Mora
didn’t “look Spanish enough” and suggested that he “wear a sombrero”
on the
air to identify himself. It didn’t take long at all for the Latino
Council on
the Media to threaten a phone and letter-writing campaign against the
station. “You can’t allow people to go on the air and say things like
that,”
said Mary Gonzalez Koenig, president of the Latino Council on the Media.
“We
can’t just let it go,” she said in a Chicago Sun-Times story. According
to
the story, “Koenig said North’s comments were racist and unfairly portrayed
Hispanics in a negative light.” Hmm … sound familiar?
“They keep telling us to mainstream, but they keep putting labels on
us and
branding us,” Koenig said in the Sun-Times story. “They wouldn’t do
that to
a non-Latino.” Well, they would; they do it to Italians all the time.
A spokeswoman for WBBM-TV in Chicago, the station Mora works at, said
of
North, “We wouldn’t even validate his statement with a comment.” “North
defended his remarks as typical of his on-air style,” the Sun-Times
story
said, “and suggested that people ‘lighten up’ and not take his comments
so
seriously.” Does any of this sound familiar? North also compared himself
to
Don Rickles. I don’t think so.
Anyway, while this doesn’t directly involve us, we may want to pay some
attention to how the Hispanic community handles this matter. It could
be
interesting.
http://www.franoi.com/
-----------------------------------------
Distributed with permission.
(Copyright 2002, Fra Noi News Service, a division of Fra Noi Inc.)
|